Skip to main content

OasisEye Specialists

TransPRK vs. ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens): Best Choice for High Myopia

High Myopia, TransPRK vs ICL

Reviewed by Dr Diymitra K Ganasan, Refractive Surgeon of OasisEye Specialists | Last updated: September 2026


 

High myopia is a common eye condition where the shape of the eye causes light entering it to focus in front of the retina instead of directly on it, resulting in clear vision for close objects but blurry vision for distant ones.

 

Understanding High Myopia

When an eye is longer from front to back than average—a shape similar to an oval rather than a round ball—light entering the eye cannot focus on the light-sensitive layer at the back (the retina). In everyday life, this means objects a few inches away might be crystal clear, but street signs, classroom whiteboards, or faces across a room appear as soft blurs.

For parents and young adults in Malaysia, managing high myopia is more than just buying thicker glasses. Very short-sighted eyes often come with a thinner front window (the cornea), making standard laser procedures less suitable and increasing the long-term need for specialized vision correction solutions.

 

Causes and Risk Factors

High myopia develops due to a combination of structural, genetic, and environmental factors:

  • Eyeball Elongation: The structural lengthening of the eye from front to back prevents light rays from reaching the back lining naturally.
  • Family History: Children with one or both parents with high short-sightedness have a higher likelihood of developing the condition due to inherited structural traits.
  • Prolonged Near Work: Extended hours of close-up tasks, such as reading or screen use without breaks, are associated with accelerated optical elongation during developmental years.
  • Reduced Outdoor Light Exposure: Spending minimal time in natural daylight during childhood reduces dopamine release in the retina, a chemical signal that helps regulate normal eye growth.

 

Staging and Severity

To determine which corrective option is appropriate, eye care professionals categorize short-sightedness by its optical power, measured in units called Diopters (D):

Stage / ClassificationDioptre RangeWhat it Means for the Patient
Mild Myopia-0.50 D to -3.00 DMinor distance blur; easily corrected with thin glasses or basic surface laser procedures.
Moderate Myopia-3.25 D to -6.00 DSignificant distance blur; daily tasks require corrective lenses. Most laser treatments are viable.
High Myopia-6.00 D to -10.00 DSevere distance blur; glasses lenses become noticeably thick and heavy. Corneal thickness becomes a limiting factor for laser treatment.
Severe / Extreme MyopiaGreater than -10.00 DVision is limited to a few inches from the face. Surface lasers may remove too much tissue, making lens implants the preferred approach.

 

Treatment Options for High Myopia

  1. TransPRK (Transepithelial Photorefractive Keratectomy)
  • What It Is: A surface-based, touchless laser vision correction procedure. An automated cool-beam laser gently removes the thin outer skin layer of the eye (epithelium) and reshapes the underlying surface in one continuous step without surgical blades or manual scraping.
  • What It Is For: Patients with moderate-to-high short-sightedness (typically up to -8.00D, depending on tissue thickness) or those with thin corneas who want to avoid creating a corneal flap (such as active individuals or contact sport athletes).
  • Honest Limitations & Risks: Because the skin layer must naturally regrow, initial recovery involves 3 to 5 days of discomfort, light sensitivity, and blurry vision. Final visual stabilization may take several weeks to months. According to a landmark study in the Journal of Refractive Surgery (2023), post-operative corneal haze occurs in roughly 1% to 2% of high myopia cases, though modern medication (Mitomycin-C) used during surgery significantly lowers this occurrence. Regression (partial return of short-sightedness) can occur over long periods.
  1. ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens)
  • What It Is: An internal additive lens procedure. A soft, biocompatible lens made of a specialized collagen-polymer material is folded and inserted through a microscopic opening, sitting permanently behind the colored part of your eye (the iris) and in front of your natural lens.
  • What It Is For: Patients with high to extreme myopia (up to -18.00 D or higher), individuals with thin or irregular corneas, or those prone to severe dry eye syndrome.
  • Honest Limitations & Risks: While ICL does not remove corneal tissue and is fully reversible, it involves intraocular (inside-the-eye) surgery. Data from the American Academy of Ophthalmology Preferred Practice Pattern (2023) indicates that internal lens placement carries a small long-term risk of elevated eye pressure or premature cataract formation (observed in approximately 1% to 3% of patients over extended follow-up periods), requiring routine annual monitoring.

Comparison FeatureTransPRK (Surface Laser)ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens)
Primary MechanismTouchless surface laser reshaping (epithelium removal and tissue ablation in one step)Permanent internal lens insertion behind the iris
Target CandidateModerate-to-high myopia (up to -8.00 D) or thin corneasHigh-to-extreme myopia (up to -18.00 D), thin/irregular corneas, or severe dry eye
Corneal Tissue RemovalYes (reshapes natural corneal tissue)No (preserves full corneal structure)
ReversibilityIrreversible (permanent tissue modification)Fully reversible (lens can be surgically removed or replaced)
Initial Healing Window3 to 5 days (discomfort, light sensitivity, temporary blur)24 to 48 hours (rapid visual restoration)
Visual StabilizationWeeks to monthsDays to weeks
Clinical Risk Profile1-2% corneal haze risk (Journal of Refractive Surgery), potential long-term regression1-3% long-term risk of pressure elevation or early cataracts (AAO PPP 2023)

 

Screening and Risk Reduction

While the physical lengthening of the eye cannot be reversed once it occurs, population-level studies demonstrate that early monitoring and tailored intervention reduce the likelihood of high-myopia complications.

  • Routine Comprehensive Dilated Exams: A yearly check of the peripheral retina allows specialists to detect and seal small retinal tears before they progress to retinal detachment.
  • Corneal Topographic Mapping: Before undergoing any refractive procedure, advanced 3D scanning maps the curvature and stability of the front window of the eye to ensure long-term safety.
  • Lifestyle Adjustments for Children: The World Health Organization (WHO) myopia guidelines note that increasing natural outdoor light exposure to at least 2 hours daily in children is associated with lower rates of myopic progression across clinical populations.

Medical Disclaimer

This article is written for general educational purposes and does not constitute medical advice. It is not a substitute for professional consultation with a qualified ophthalmologist. Individual clinical situations vary, and management decisions should always be made in partnership with your treating specialist.



References

  1. Aljaberi, H. A., Ali, I. R., & Noori, Z. T. M. (2025). Comparative clinical outcomes of SMILE, femtosecond LASIK, and transepithelial PRK: A multicenter comparative cohort study. BMC Ophthalmology, 25(1), Article 4162. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12886-025-04162-0 

  2. American Academy of Ophthalmology Cornea and External Disease Panel. (2023). Refractive errors & refractive surgery preferred practice pattern®. American Academy of Ophthalmology. https://www.aao.org/education/preferred-practice-pattern/refractive-errors-refractive-surgery-ppp

  3. Moshirfar, M., Wang, Q., Theis, J., Porter, K. C., Stoakes, I. M., Payne, C. J., & Hoopes, P. C. (2023). Management of corneal haze after photorefractive keratectomy. Ophthalmology and Therapy, 12(6), 2841–2862. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40123-023-00782-1 

  4. Wannapanich, T., Kasetsuwan, N., & Reinprayoon, U. (2023). Intraocular implantable collamer lens with a central hole implantation: Safety, efficacy, and patient outcomes. Clinical Ophthalmology, 17, 969–980. https://doi.org/10.2147/OPTH.S379856

  5. World Health Organization. (2021). The WHO myopia impact report: Global guidelines for myopia prevention and management. World Health Organization.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

For patients with thin corneas or high prescriptions, TransPRK is often considered safer structurally because it preserves more underlying tissue strength and creates no corneal flap. A flap created during LASIK can weaken an already thin cornea, whereas TransPRK keeps the structural integrity intact. Your specialist will determine eligibility based on your specific corneal thickness scans.

Yes. One major advantage of the Implantable Collamer Lens (ICL) is that it is additive and reversible. If your prescription changes significantly or if you require cataract surgery later in life, a refractive surgeon can safely remove or replace the lens through a brief, routine procedure.

ICL offers near-instant visual recovery; most patients notice clear vision within 24 to 48 hours with minimal physical discomfort. TransPRK requires a longer healing period because the outer skin layer of the eye must regrow. Expect 3 to 5 days of rest while wearing a protective contact lens, with full visual clarity developing gradually over 1 to 3 months.

TransPRK and ICL both carry a lower risk of long-term dry eye compared to traditional flap-based lasers. TransPRK does not disrupt deeper corneal nerves, and ICL does not alter corneal tissue at all. Temporary dryness can occur during initial healing, but long-term dry eye rates remain low in both options.

Laser procedures reshape existing tissue, while ICL provides a fixed optical correction. While the surgery itself is permanent, the natural eye can still undergo subtle age-related changes over time. According to clinical follow-up data published in BMC Ophthalmology (2025), minor regression or prescription shift can occur in a small percentage of high myopia cases years after treatment, which can often be managed or fine-tuned if necessary.